Libel Smackdown

Janice Winowski does not have a libel case because there is no proof of actual malice or reckless disregard for the truth. The reporters attempted to learn the truth of Winowski's situation with alcohol by calling the secretary of the courthouse. Just because reporters were not given information doesn't mean they were reckless. What is more, if Winowski finished top 5 on American Idol then she recorded on the American Idol Album. As such, while the season she was on the show is long over, her music is still available to the public. She put herself in the spotlight through the show and remained there by participating on an album and marrying a Survivor contestant.